Funny Alltop Heading

Author: Gerry | Created: 2009-12-17 20:19 | Last Activity: 2009-12-21 17:02

Original Post

2009-12-17 20:19
I was reviewing the Alltop website, which aggregates content, One of the groupings you can see there is the David Allen one. You get content viewed by him I guess.

He is listed there as Creator of GTD Movement. I got a laugh out of this. I guess one of the tried and true ways to make money in America is to head a religion, cult or movement. I don't think my USGTM group can give GTD a run for its money yet, but I'll bet if the AF 1-4, DIT and GED people banded together they could.

Gerry

htttp://www.simple-time-management.com

Reply by Jacqueline

2009-12-17 22:00
Well it worked for L. Ron.
Mark just needs to get Mike to get on Oprah and jump up and down on a couch like a crazed madman.
I know it's old, but I need a laugh:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRbhE3GRiUE&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PoP8-905xlk&feature=related

Reply by Mike

2009-12-18 10:48
Nothing picks up true believers more than a guru. Remember that DA has a history with being a true believer so ...

As to the couch bit ... hell, why not give it a try, I say ;-)

Reply by Jacqueline

2009-12-18 14:35

Reply by Mike

2009-12-19 5:41
Jacqueline,

Yeah, like that. But the posts there seem a bit over the top. I'm too tired to read them carefully right now but they sound a bit paranoid. Personally, while I think GtD appeals to those who have certain personality issues, I don't see it as brainwashing in any way. But hey, what do I know ;-) I would like to see him in person or a longish interview so I could read how he comes across.

Reply by Jacqueline

2009-12-19 17:25
Well, there was that Wired interview with him where he talks about being committed to a mental hospital and the heroin addiction. Not that there's anything wrong with that...

http://forum.rickross.com/read.php?4,14869,page=3

David Allan doing a love-bomb session (it's kind of a cute pic):
http://www.ndh.org/slideshow.php3?category=AUG2003_SUPER2&id=43&srcnum=

The only issue that I would have is two things - I am really reluctant to put my money into something that funds something that I have a problem with. Like if I were pro-life and donated money to the United Way in an area where the United Way funds Planned Parenthood. So being a non-believer in J-R's Mystical Traveler stuff, I would have a hard time putting much money into something that funds John-Rogers MSIA.

Secondly, maybe it's asking too much, but I do like full disclosure on some things or what someone's involved with so I can spot what to weed out or figure out where something is (possibly) leading to when you go deeper.

It does seem like a lot of these programs go together with the old LGAT's - Jinny Ditzler (Your Best Year Yet) was an estie, Debbie Ford was involved in Landmark, Arianna Huffington is an MSIA (which took some stuff from Lifespring) person like David Allan ... What do I know, I like those kinds of seminars too on a pretty shallow level.

So what is Mark Forster hiding?!? LOL
Is he subversively attempting to get us to join choirs or to retire and take up ballet?
Speaking of choirboys...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m5iHUziPIAI

Reply by Mark Forster

2009-12-19 21:17
<< So what is Mark Forster hiding? >>

It sounds very boring - but nothing really.

Reply by Peter Knight

2009-12-19 23:30
<>

with the amount of books you've read I think you don't need the background info on an author to weed out a 'hidden agenda' a text might have, you've got a well honed inner-BS detector already perfected. I know I have!

Reply by Jacqueline

2009-12-19 23:41
Peter, I know (or hope) that's the case now, but when I was younger... some of that New Age stuff was pretty damaging to my practicality - and time management practices - for quite a lot of years. Magical thinking (like LOA) made me incredibly unproductive. :-)

Reply by Mike

2009-12-20 0:00
Jaqueline,

>>> Well, there was that Wired interview with him where he talks about being committed to a mental hospital and the heroin addiction. Not that there's anything wrong with that... <<<

LOL ;-) But if I knew that in advance of getting into GtD, I'd drop it fast.

>>> The only issue that I would have is two things - I am really reluctant to put my money into something that funds something that I have a problem with. <<<

Well, yeah! In fact, there is a motivational system (an alarm clock, actually) that donates money to causes you hate in order to get you going. ;-)

>>> Like if I were pro-life and donated money to the United Way in an area where the United Way funds Planned Parenthood. So being a non-believer in J-R's Mystical Traveler stuff, I would have a hard time putting much money into something that funds John-Rogers MSIA. <<<

I have a hard time putting money into anything. I read GtD and tried to use it for the time management value. I never had any interest in donating or even buying any seminars or lectures or ... If the idea makes sense, I can use it on hearing it. If I need extensive lectures to understand it, I'll never get involved with it.

>>> Secondly, maybe it's asking too much, but I do like full disclosure on some things or what someone's involved with so I can spot what to weed out or figure out where something is (possibly) leading to when you go deeper. <<<

Yeah, I know what you mean. But now that you have experience, as you say later, you can spot it a mile away.

>>> It does seem like a lot of these programs go together with the old LGAT's - Jinny Ditzler (Your Best Year Yet) was an estie, Debbie Ford was involved in Landmark, Arianna Huffington is an MSIA (which took some stuff from Lifespring) person like David Allan ... What do I know, I like those kinds of seminars too on a pretty shallow level. <<<

Yes, and a lot of them come out of Provo, UT as well. There and Santa Barbara, CA ;-) There is a strong similarity and lineage there, that's for sure.

Reply by Mark Forster

2009-12-20 9:38
Jacqueline:
<< Well, there was that Wired interview with him where he talks about being committed to a mental hospital and the heroin addiction. Not that there's anything wrong with that... >>

... compared with NOT being committed to a mental hospital or addicted to heroin, you mean?

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2009-12-20 10:07
I think Jacqueline means we all make mistakes sometimes. We all deserve a second chance. And we shouldn't judge people based on mistakes they made in the past when they've seen the error of their ways and repented.

I couldn't care less if DA was a heroin addict at some point in time, even though I'm so anti-drugs that I don't even smoke or drink alcohol myself. The dubious religious sect thing is worrying me more, but I've read GTD several times already and I didn't find anything suspicious in there. At least not more than in time management books of other Christian authors. So since I'll never follow one guru exclusively but just pick up things here and there that make sense to me, I'm not too concerned here either.

Reply by Mark Forster

2009-12-20 13:01
Andreas:

<< I think Jacqueline means we all make *mistakes* sometimes. We all deserve a second chance. And we shouldn't judge people based on *mistakes* they made in the past when they've seen the *error* of their ways and *repented*. >> [my emphases]

In other words you *do* think there is something wrong with being committed to a mental hospital and being addicted to heroin?

I certainly agree with you that people should be given a second chance if they have pulled themselves out of things like this, but that wasn't what Jacqueline said.

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2009-12-20 13:11
<>

I certainly think taking heroin is wrong because you are destroying yourself. Like I said don't even drink alcohol, because I see it only as a less efficient and slower method of destroying oneself. I don't think being an former heroin addict is wrong (which I think Jacqueline meant) and I don't think being committed to a mental hospital is wrong.

Disclaimer to explain my standpoint: My father was an alcoholic and killed himself when I was 15. I spent some weeks in a mental hospital while coping with issues I had resulting from that.

Reply by Mark Forster

2009-12-20 13:56
Andreas:

I think the question that immediately comes into people's minds when they hear someone say that they were in mental hospital and were a heroin addict is not "What a wicked person!", but "How much can one rely on the teaching of someone with a history like that?"

In the case of someone like David Allan who teaches a time management system, it probably doesn't matter that much. His system stands or falls on its own merits, not his.

But with many "gurus" it would matter a lot. Would you want your children in a cult run by someone with a history of mental illness and addiction? So I was challenging Jacqueline not on the question of whether it was morally wrong, but on the question of whether it mattered.

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2009-12-20 15:39
<>

The answer that first springs to mind is that I'd prefer my children not joining any cults at all, if possible. And I would have more of a problem with a guru being someone who currently uses drugs (or even encourages others to do so) than with with one who used to do so, but doesn't do that anymore. Overcoming such things at least shows a tremendous amount of willpower. And not trying to hide past mistakes takes some courage.

Reply by moises

2009-12-20 16:41
Actually, Jinny Ditzler, author of Your Best Year yet is also a follower of the Mystical Traveler. The very first page of her book contains Acknowledgments including: "To my greatest teachers: Werner Erhard, who gave me the keys to my power; John-Roger, who opened my heat; and Lew Epstein, who showed me how to let myself be loved."

I am an atheist (though not a member of any atheist organization). I wonder how people of faith can be so wrongheaded. Nonetheless, I found, amazingly, that some of them--including Mark Forster and Mel--have some wonderful things to teach me.

As others have written, these methods and counsels need to stand or fall on their merits. Attacking a time management system by attacking the beliefs of that system's advocate is the paradigm of an _ad hominem_ argument. It reminds me of Stalin rejecting what we would today call computer science, because it was based on Aristotelian, rather than Hegelian, logic. He kept the USSR ideologically pure and set back its technological development even further. I could limit myself to studying the work of atheists only. That might keep me ideologically pure. But would it really serve my overall wellbeing?

Reply by Mark Forster

2009-12-20 16:42
Andreas:

So we've gone from saying that there's nothing wrong with these things to saying they are a positive advantage?

Well, I will admit that I am very proud of having given up a 30-a-day cigarette habit in 1974. But I still think it would have been better if I'd never had the habit in the first place.

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2009-12-20 16:52
<>

If you mean "overcoming addictions" by "these things", then yes.

<>

You have every right to be proud. Of course it would have been better to never start. But it would be far worse to never stop.

Reply by Jacqueline

2009-12-20 16:59
Mark and Andreas,

I just referenced the mental hospital and addiction because that was what I had remembered from the article as it was so surprising, and the keywords in the google search I did to re-find it. The only thing it would suggest to me is that someone who has had difficulties like that might feel a need for more control in their lives than someone who hasn't had those experiences, so their system would probably reflect that. Like the article says in what I've excerpted below, which I really don't agree with. I tend to think most things aren't as complex as we make them out to be.

"He realizes that his system can be difficult and that he's often accused of going overboard with elaborate schemes. He responds with a shrug. "Look, the workings of an automatic transmission are more complicated than a manual transmission," he says. "To simplify a complex event, you need a complex system." "

It doesn't concern me when an individual gets their information from a book or site like GTD or Covey as someone can easily take or leave what they read in a book. Where I would be cautious in a circumstance like this is with the individual coaching services that are also provided by that company. From what I've read, the leaders in that company are all members / ministers of MSIA.

I don't even think that particular MSIA group is evil, just kind of new age / alternate Christianity. So if I was getting coaching from someone in that group, I would want to know exactly what their philosophies were in case they recommended that I go to a workshop or seminar because the teachings would conflict with my own beliefs. (Which, don't worry Mark - I will not elaborate on here!) Or were coaching me from that perspective.

I wonder too if perhaps some of the teachings that DA has put into GTD which are right from the old Lifespring training (eg. extreme rigidness to keeping commitments) aren't a good thing anyway. Taking the extreme rigidness out of it. But I prefer the AF philosophy of not sticking rigidly to commitments but to pare them down to what is manageable for you and what you really want or need to do (which is what "stands out" and dismissal means to me).

This is the seminar company that DA references when he talks about what he did as a seminar leader for years before forming the DA company:
http://www.icsahome.com/logon/elibdocview.asp?Subject=Light+on+Insight

And this is the type of thing that really bugs me, bilking people when they're emotionally vulnerable is just wrong:

"(A "Gift of Giving" session was added at the end of the five-day Insight seminar in which some people were so euphoric that they made out $10,000 checks to the group.) MSIA recruited many Insight graduates, although the link between the two organizations - Insight trainers were usually MSIA ministers, the two shared an idiosyncratic philosophy, and Insight reportedly "tithed" to MSIA - was unknown to seminar attendees."

And given that I've been on these things before, I know how easy it is to take advantage of people when they really aren't thinking clearly.

Maybe I'm over-sensitive about this stuff, but I was introduced to the LOA world and way of thinking years ago by a personal coach before I had a BS detector in place, and it really did mess with my productivity - and life in general - for a long time.

Andreas, I wanted to say that I am so sorry about your loss.

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2009-12-20 16:59
I'm not saying someone who got addicted and overcame it has an advantage over someone who never got addicted in the first place. I'm just saying overcoming an addiction is hard and I can respect people who do so. I don't feel very secure about my ability to do the same, so I take great care to stay clear of drugs of any kind.

Reply by Mark Forster

2009-12-20 17:06
Moises:

<< I could limit myself to studying the work of atheists only. That might keep me ideologically pure. But would it really serve my overall wellbeing? >>

I think you ought to be very wary. When I was an atheist I thought something similar, and I ended up as a Roman Catholic. You can never be too careful!

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2009-12-20 17:09
Jacqueline:

Thank you, but that was a really long time ago.

I agree those seminars smell fishy. But then, I'm wary of any form of organized religion, especially when money is exchanged for salvation.

Reply by Mark Forster

2009-12-20 17:14
Andreas:

<< I'm just saying overcoming an addiction is hard and I can respect people who do so. >>

I imagine giving up heroin is much harder than giving up smoking, but my experiences with smoking tell me that an ex-smoker is a smoker who has temporarily stopped smoking.

I've managed to temporarily stop smoking for a very long time now, but I know that if even now I took one puff of a cigarette I would be straight back on cigarettes again.

The fact is that any sort of serious addiction changes one for the rest of one's life, and there is always the danger of a relapse.

Reply by Jacqueline

2009-12-20 17:38
Hi moises, with Jinny D., you wrote "John-Roger, who opened my heat" - I think you meant heart, but it gave me a good laugh!

I feel the same way as you do, but I still like to know what the agenda is - or if there is the possibility of one. Instead, I sound like some wacko conspiracy theorist, and I'm really not! :-)

Reply by Jacqueline

2009-12-20 17:56
Mark,

I totally agree with you, I had quit smoking for 10 years and had one and got hooked again.

I think that many things are like this so it pays to be very conscious of it. Generally, people will say "do something for 21 days, and it will become a habit and part of you" - not true!

Every time I've gone into workaholic mode, I've stopped exercising. Every time I don't have external accountability and don't plan out my life in some way via using a list or scheduling etc., my time just drifts away and isn't used very wisely. It's kind of a bummer, but accepting the reality of it makes it much easier to deal with.

Reply by moises

2009-12-20 18:47
Back in my GTD days, I exchanged a few e-mails with one of their employees. He had his own blog, and he also posted on David Allen's website. I had made some posts about the more profound, unstated, assumptions that, at that time, I thought underlay GTD. This GTD employee wrote me a personal e-mail thanking me for my comments and adding some comments of his own that continued the conversation. (By the way, my theology or lack thereof was unknown to this employee and did not figure in the posts that I had made.)

This guy did not try to recruit me to anything. He just was interested in continuing the discussion of time management.

Soon after that, some anti-cult people started going after David Allen bigtime. My attitude was one of bemusement. If Allen's cult did something truly illegal, then I think they should throw the book at them. But most of the accusations I have read were along the lines of the concept of a Mystical Traveler is bizarre and many things that his followers believe are bizarre. My response was, "bizarre compared to what?" The beliefs of any religion that I have studied strike me as bizarre.

The argument that was being made against GTD was that it was a "totalizing" system. Presumably, this meant that you were to put everything in your life into the system. What was never clear to me was how this was causally linked to my being brainwashed to follow the Mystical Traveler. Mark, just a few entries above, jokingly told me to beware AF's subtle influence on my beliefs. But, of course, he was joking and I get the joke. Even if Mark's Catholicism enabled him to conceive and perfect AF, its contribution to my productivity can be evaluated independently of its religious origins.

Aristotle, like virtually all ancient Athenian citizens, supported slavery. Is that a good reason to oppose syllogistic reasoning?

I no longer see much value in GTD, now that I've become comfortable with Mark's systems. But I am still willing to give David Allen a vigorous defense against what I perceive to be some low blows. Please understand, I find his belief in the Mystical Traveler as intellectually offensive as anyone. But if I only defended those with whom I agreed against ad hominem arguments, what kind of credibility would I deserve?

Reply by Rainer

2009-12-20 19:09
Thanks, Moises!

Reply by Peter Knight

2009-12-20 20:49
<>

Interesting phrasing, you made me look up 'wrongheaded'. What's your definition?
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/wrong-headed
kind of a bold paragraph depending on how you read it!

(ps. I'm non-religious non-atheist, a free agent if you will)

Reply by Man of Kent

2009-12-20 23:42
Where a speaker mentions religious conviction it can cause the message to be heard quite differently. Tony Blair played down his religiion for many years for this reason. David Allen may play down his spiritual activities so that his message on time management is heard.

Reply by Mike

2009-12-21 0:55
GEEEEEZ, I go out to shovel the driveway and I'm late to one of the best conversations lately ;-)

Moises,

>>> I am an atheist (though not a member of any atheist organization). <<<

First of all ... when I say that I am "an atheist", I do so only because that is the inane way our society needs to formulate ideas. In my view, no one is "an atheist". It is not something one IS. Because society in general is so daffy as to believe in things that do not exist and demand that everyone do, one is basically forced to take on a label for not doing so. I simply do NOT accept the beliefs others have in what does not exist. That is all the term means. How silly would it if people started calling themselves "achocolate eaters" or "a tocoists" or whatever. That we even have such a term as "atheist" is nuts.

;-) ;-)

>>> I wonder how people of faith can be so wrongheaded. <<<

People of EVERYTHING can be wrongheaded. That is how people are, yes? I really don't think that any belief in particular group of people have a monopoly on wrongheadness ;-) ;-)

>>>Nonetheless, I found, amazingly, that some of them--including Mark Forster and Mel--have some wonderful things to teach me. <<<

LOL ;-)

>>> As others have written, these methods and counsels need to stand or fall on their merits. Attacking a time management system by attacking the beliefs of that system's advocate is the paradigm of an _ad hominem_ argument. It reminds me of Stalin rejecting what we would today call computer science, because it was based on Aristotelian, rather than Hegelian, logic. He kept the USSR ideologically pure and set back its technological development even further. I could limit myself to studying the work of atheists only. That might keep me ideologically pure. But would it really serve my overall well being. <<<

The thing is, people are basically consistent, at some level or other ;-) If a guy joins cults, one has to question his reasoning about the best way to do filing. True, if it IS the best way, judged by your own standards and needs, then fine. But, working backward, I am able to explain why his way of doing things is wrong for me because his personality has some "glitches".

Reply by Norman U.

2009-12-21 1:08
"GEEEEEZ, I go out to shovel the driveway and I'm late to one of the best conversations lately"

If you get out of your driveway, you won't be able to avoid better.

Reply by Mike

2009-12-21 1:27
Jacqueline,

>>> And given that I've been on these things before, I know how easy it is to take advantage of people when they really aren't thinking clearly. <<<

That really goes on a lot ... and especially with seminars. Bilking others seems to be an acceptable marketing philosophy these days. Disgusting.

>>> Maybe I'm over-sensitive about this stuff, but I was introduced to the LOA world and way of thinking years ago by a personal coach before I had a BS detector in place, and it really did mess with my productivity - and life in general - for a long time. <<<

I hear ya. And I understand your anger ... and would be angry as well.

I also understand the argument that ideas have to stand on their own. My example is Tony Robbins. He picked up some very good ideas and marketed them well ... but he set up a marketing empire that, in the long run, took advantage of people and bilked many people. If you stuck with his program, you'd wind up paying tens of thousands of dollars for an advanced seminar and even more for individual counseling. I got what there was to be gotten from a $10 book. There was really no more to it than what was in the book. Likewise there is no more to DA's seminars and counseling sessions than is in the first book. The rest is all just a swindle, to put it bluntly. Not that he does not have a right to market has he sees fit. But there are ethical considerations.

Reply by Mike

2009-12-21 1:33
Mark,

>>> << I could limit myself to studying the work of atheists only. That might keep me ideologically pure. But would it really serve my overall wellbeing? >>

I think you ought to be very wary. When I was an atheist I thought something similar, and I ended up as a Roman Catholic. You can never be too careful! <<<

ROTFLMAO ;-) When I was a Roman Catholic I thought something similar and ended up as an atheist ... you can never be too careful ;-) ;-)

Reply by Mike

2009-12-21 2:07
Jacqueline,

>>> Instead, I sound like some wacko conspiracy theorist, and I'm really not! :-) <<<

No, you don't sound wacko. You make a lot of good sense.

Reply by David Drake

2009-12-21 3:55
I think saying that the rest of what the David Allen company does "is a swindle" beyond his first book is off the mark and a little strong. How about everyone stop trying so hard to tear down other systems that you may not like or can't make work or whatever, and discuss the attributes and positive things that many in the time management field have brought to the table.

My two cents worth....let's stay positive people.

-David

Reply by Mike

2009-12-21 4:54
Hi David,

>>> I think saying that the rest of what the David Allen company does "is a swindle" beyond his first book is off the mark and a little strong. <<<

It may be strong, but it also may be warranted.

>>> How about everyone stop trying so hard to tear down other systems that you may not like or can't make work or whatever, <<<

If you've been following the thread, it is not so much the techniques or how well they work, but how the personal beliefs of the person has influenced them. There are legitimate questions being asked.

>>> and discuss the attributes and positive things that many in the time management field have brought to the table. <<<

I think this whole forum is about that. This single thread is discussing the beliefs of the man so I don't see what the problem is.

>>> My two cents worth....let's stay positive people. <<<

Yeah, that might be politically correct, but things are what they are and painting everything white makes the world look ... well, like it does now ... after this snow storm. Kind of boring. ;-)

Have a wonderful holiday, David.

Reply by Mark Forster

2009-12-21 9:25
Mike:

<< How silly would it if people started calling themselves "achocolate eaters" or "a tocoists" or whatever. That we even have such a term as "atheist" is nuts. >>

I don't think there's a term for a non-chocolate eater (perhaps because 90% of people say they eat chocolate and the other 10% are liars), but we definitely talk about non-smokers (or was that a typo for a-taco-ists, since you were talking about food?).

Perhaps you should call yourself a "Bright" a la Richard Dawkins. That has the right ring about it.

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2009-12-21 9:39
<>

I have to say more-rational-than-thou doesn't really seem more appealing than holier-than-thou. I don't have anything against theist or atheists (like Peter I'm neither, I would describe myself as an agnostic), but I don't like it when people arrogantly belittle other people's belief systems and go on and on about how their belief system is the one Truth(TM). I see that mostly with religious people, but there are also some atheist zealots that act that way. (A this point, those atheists will jump me and claim that "atheism isn't a belief system, it's the lack of a belief system, therefore there can be no atheist zealots". but that's not true in my opinion. Theists believe in a god (or gods) without proof, atheists *believe* there is no god(s) without proof - there all belief systems.)

I should probably stop rambling on about things that will offend everyone besides the 0.0001% of humanity that agree with me. ^_^

Reply by Peter Knight

2009-12-21 13:49
I think the belittling of beliefs occurs ubiquitously, if not especially among those that take a purely scientific point of view. Richard Dawkins thrives on it and he'd like to see religions change because if he puts it bluntly they are supposedly stupid.

Science to me is just as much of a religion. One can't even practice science without having bias or a belief system effecting its results. There's no real way around that, but some scientists thinks science is truly objective. What makes me find a certain dogmatic scientific approach hypocritical, especially when someone like Richard Dawkins 'preaches it', is that they commit the same errors as organized religions have commonly practiced it. When someone starts dictating what the right way of thinking ought to be, I don't care under what guise it is, for me the red flags go up.

Science might appeal more as a rational upgrade because it feels like it explains things in ways we can grasp in a more tangible way, but at the same time is severely limited in answering a multitude of meaningful questions. Science can only validate what it can measure - right now we can measure a couple of dimensions. Some scientists claim there are over a dozen dimensions. Who knows, but currently science tries to explain everything with what it can measure with these few dimensions. By definition it has a limited lens. The trouble is that scientists fall into a trap thinking that everything can be explained in the dimensions we can measure and when it does not, other theories are considered magical thinking and religious. To me that is the ultimate in ignorant arrogance.

Point in case, if you watch a intelligent design versus evolution debate. If you so much hint at believing or considering an intelligent design approach, the 'evolutionists' will ridicule you.

What's funny to me is that the population that partake in religion are statistically across the board happier than those that do not practice or believe in a certain religion.

Reply by David Drake

2009-12-21 14:26
I still do not think trashing the David Allen company and David Allen in particular is warranted. Thinking positive about things does not mean I think the world is always a wonderful place.

I do not think I wish to be on this forum anymore as I do not like the way things are going here. I am leaving. I am sure I will not be missed. Best regards to all of you here that wanted to discuss AF and time management systems. I am moving back to the GTD forums.

-David

Reply by Gerry

2009-12-21 15:52
Wow, just saw what happened to this thread. My intention in starting it was not to in anyway trash David Allen or GTD. I was just pointing out that in America organizations and leaders who can create a religious like following can use it sell lots of products and enrich themselves. I found time management one of the funnier ways to build that type of following as compared to religion, politics etc.

I have enjoyed David's posts here and on my board and certainly apologize to Mark if I caused a loyal reader to leave his forum

Gerry

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2009-12-21 15:54
<>

Well, I hope no one over there has an opinion different from your own so you don't have to leave there too. I've explained above why I don't have a problem with some of the things some people hold against David Allen. Others, like Mike, see things differently. And that's okay.

If you really are unsatisfied with the ways this whole forum with all people in it has developed, then you should leave. But because of one thread with a topic you don't like and a few people who are strongely sceptical of something you aren't sceptical of?

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2009-12-21 15:58
Gerry:

It's a sad fact - to derail any forum, make a post about anything remotely connected to religion or politics, sit back and watch.

Reply by David Drake

2009-12-21 15:59
I said I was leaving. Best wishes to everyone, especially Mark Forster, who I think is the best. And is has nothing to do with having everyone agree with my opinions. Andreas, you think what you want.

-David

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2009-12-21 16:02
<>

Looks like I'll have no choice, since I don't understand what the problem really is and you won't explain.

I wish you good luck, you where a great forum member to have around.

Reply by Mike

2009-12-21 16:07
Hi Mark,

>>>I don't think there's a term for a non-chocolate eater (perhaps because 90% of people say they eat chocolate and the other 10% are liars), <<<

ROTFLMAO ;-)

>>> but we definitely talk about non-smokers <<<

Well, firstly, I'd say that the term "non-smoker" is only a kind of politically correct term. I don't smoke and I would never think of calling myself a "non-smoker". Rather I'd say, if asked if I wanted to light up, that "I do not smoke". There is something really wrong about defining one's identity with one's actions. Don't you think?

>>> (or was that a typo for a-taco-ists, since you were talking about food?).

Yeah, I had just come back from Taco Bell and burritos were on my mind (or my palate) ;-)

>>> Perhaps you should call yourself a "Bright" a la Richard Dawkins. That has the right ring about it. <<<

Sorry, I don't get the reference, I'll look it up when I get back from last minute shopping.

Reply by Mike

2009-12-21 16:15
Andreas,

>>> I don't like it when people arrogantly belittle other people's belief systems and go on and on about how their belief system is the one Truth(TM). <<<

An argument for another time, but I'd say that "Truth" (with a capital "T") does not exist.

>>> I see that mostly with religious people, but there are also some atheist zealots that act that way. <<<

Oh no doubt. There are atheists clubs and groups you can join ... they probably even have jackets. But that seems a bit wacko to me.

>>> (A this point, those atheists will jump me and claim that "atheism isn't a belief system, it's the lack of a belief system, therefore there can be no atheist zealots". but that's not true in my opinion. <<<

Well, holding the atheist viewpoint does not make one a zealot ... but people can be zealots about anything. Being a zealot is a question of how you act, not what you believe.

>>> Theists believe in a god (or gods) without proof, atheists *believe* there is no god(s) without proof - there all belief systems.) <<<

Well, not precisely. The pure atheist position is that holding any position requires proof and if you posit ANYTHING and put it outside the realm of proof then you can't demand acceptance of that position. While a ton of atheists are activists, atheism, per se, is entirely passive, in that regard. It would be like someone claiming the existence of little green men but only HE could even see them. You'd shrug and walk off to get your taco. (Mmmmmm, tacos ;-)

>>> I should probably stop rambling on about things that will offend everyone besides the 0.0001% of humanity that agree with me. ^_^ <<<

Not so much rambling as putting forth interesting ideas.

Reply by Mike

2009-12-21 16:21
David,

I'm sorry you took offense and see leaving as the way to engage with others who are having a perfectly wonderful discussion. We have divergent views, have freely expressed them, and are all getting along. It seems as if differing opinions, per se, bother you. That is too bad. You are a neat guy with much to offer. But if I have to keep my trap shut to please anyone, that is outside the bounds of what I'm willing to do.

Why not consider sticking around and engaging others in intelligent debate. No one will throw sticks and stones ... or likely, even call you bad names ;-)

Reply by Jacqueline

2009-12-21 16:27
“Like religion, politics, and family planning, cereal is not a topic to be brought up in public. It's too controversial.” - Erma Bombeck

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2009-12-21 16:32
Mike:

<< The pure atheist position is that holding any position requires proof and if you posit ANYTHING and put it outside the realm of proof then you can't demand acceptance of that position. While a ton of atheists are activists, atheism, per se, is entirely passive, in that regard. >>

What you describe as "pure" atheist position is for me to a degree agnosticism - I can't claim truth if I don't don't have proof. And in my mind that goes for atheism - or what you call "active" atheism - itself as well. You say there's no way a god can exist? Proof it. (Babelfishs don't count. ;-)

Reply by smileypete

2009-12-21 16:52
I largely agree with what David Drake said, and thought his comments were intelligent, well considered, and, right on the mark

Reply by Mark Forster

2009-12-21 17:02
Oh, dear, I leave this forum for a couple of hours and look what happens!

Let's move on to something uncontroversial like global warming.